The Christmas Party That Ended Up at the Fair Work Commission

It was a Friday in mid December 2014, and a large NSW construction joint venture was holding its staff Christmas party at a hotel. It was booked for four hours, from 6pm to 10pm. The drinks were free, and staff could help themselves. Nobody was really keeping an eye on how much anyone was drinking.

One of the guests was a team leader who had been promoted only a couple of months earlier. He had a couple of beers before he arrived. Over the course of the night, he became drunk, abusive and offensive towards colleagues. After the official party wound up, he kept drinking with some workmates at another bar, where his conduct towards female colleagues led to allegations of sexual harassment.

In the days after, complaints came in. The company met with him before the Christmas break, then dismissed him when he returned from leave in January.

He took the company to the Fair Work Commission, and he won.

How the employer lost a case it should have won

Nobody, including the Commission, thought his behaviour was acceptable. But the employer had made two big mistakes.

The first was the alcohol. The Commission was critical that the company had served alcohol without limits and without any real control, then sought to hold an intoxicated employee fully responsible for what followed. It treated the employer's own approach to alcohol as a factor in the employee's favour.

The second was the process. The dismissal rested on conduct after the official function had ended, at a separate bar, which the Commission found was not connected closely enough to his work. The behaviour at the party itself was treated as out of character and isolated. On top of that, the Commission found problems with how the disciplinary process was run.

The result was that a business with genuinely upset staff, and a manager who had behaved badly, ended up on the wrong side of an unfair dismissal decision.

Why this matters more in 2026 than it did then

It would be easy to read this as a story about employment law. It is really a story about planning, and the rules have tightened since 2014.

Since December 2022, employers have had a positive duty under the Sex Discrimination Act to take reasonable and proportionate steps to eliminate sexual harassment, rather than waiting to respond after it happens. In NSW, the psychosocial hazards Code of Practice, which became enforceable from 1 July 2026, treats sexual harassment and aggression as hazards to be managed like any other.

In other words, a work function is a workplace, and the question is not only how you deal with bad behaviour afterwards. It is what you did beforehand to make it less likely.

How to plan a party that is safe and still fun

None of this means cancelling Christmas … no bah humbugs here! It means putting the same thought into your end of year function that you would put into any other work activity with known risks.

Control the alcohol. Use responsible service, have staff or bar service rather than self-serve, set a drinks limit or tab, and put on plenty of food and good non-alcoholic options.

Set a clear start and finish time, and make it obvious when the work event has ended. Avoid managers organising or paying for an "after party", which blurs that line.

Remind people of expected behaviour before the event. A short, friendly message that the usual workplace standards still apply is enough, and it gives you something to point to later.

Plan how people get home. Arrange transport or cab vouchers, especially for anyone who has been drinking.

Make sure leaders know their role on the night. Someone senior should stay sober enough to step in early, and staff should know who to go to if something makes them uncomfortable.

If something does happen, follow a fair process. Take complaints seriously, investigate properly, give the person a chance to respond, and keep records. A rushed decision can turn a clear case into a lost one.

Get your policies ready before the invitations go out

If you are not confident your sexual harassment, alcohol or conduct policies would hold up, or that your leaders know what to do on the night, book a free 30 minute Safety Health Check with Glen Dunkley, our Managing Director. It is a practical conversation, with no sales pitch, about what to tighten up before party season.

Our free WHS course also covers psychosocial hazards and your duty to prevent harm, in plain language and in under 30 minutes.

This article is general information only and is not legal advice.

Sources

Next
Next

He Said He Was Fine